Skip to main content

Table 4 Comparison of the CRISPR-GBS assay with several current GBS detection methods

From: CRISPR/Cas12a-based assay for the rapid and high-sensitivity detection of Streptococcus agalactiae colonization in pregnant women with premature rupture of membrane

 

RT-PCR [13]

RT-LAMP [12]

RT-RPA [11]

CRISPR-GBS

LoD

2–3 genome copies

300 pg μL−1

98 genomic copies

5 copies μL−1

Cross-reaction

No

No

No

No

Turnaround time

Detection time of 35 min (exclude DNA extraction)

Detection time of 60 min (exclude DNA extraction)

Detection time of 30 min (exclude DNA extraction)

Turnaround time of 35 min (include DNA extraction)

DNA extraction

DNA extraction kit (G NOME kit)

DNA extraction kit

DNA extraction kit (BD GeneOhmâ„¢ Strep B kit)

Heating lysis

Target

cfb gene

fbs gene

cfb gene

cfb gene

Temperature

Temperature cycling

A constant temperature of 63 ℃

A constant temperature of 39 ℃

A constant temperature of 37 ℃

Clinical samples

15 vaginal swabs

None

50 vaginal/anal samples

179 vaginal/ cervical swabs

Cost

Unknown

Unknown

Around $ 10

Around $ 0.6138 [23, 24]